Key points
- The Supreme Court on Friday allowed a one-time lighting of the Karthigai Deepam at the Deepathoon on November 24.
- Only a restricted Devasthanam team and officials may go up; the public, processions and slogans are barred.
- The court stayed the High Court's January 6 judgment (paragraphs 1 to 140) and listed the appeals for the second week of January 2027.
The Supreme Court on Friday stayed the Madras High Court’s findings on the Thiruparankundram hill dispute and allowed the Karthigai Deepam lamp to be lit at the Deepathoon, a stone pillar near a dargah above Madurai, as a one-time measure on November 24. A bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi said the lighting cannot be cited as proof of custom, and the main appeals will be heard in the second week of January 2027.
The court gave the “peculiar nature of the occasion” and the nearness of the festival as its reasons. In its words, as reported, the opportunity to perform the ceremony on that day, if denied, “cannot be restored by any subsequent adjudication”.
What the order says
The court stayed paragraphs 1 to 140 of the High Court Division Bench’s judgment of January 6, 2026, in so far as they are challenged, until further orders. It then set out a narrow arrangement.
A restricted team organised by the temple’s Devasthanam will light the lamp. The Madurai District Collector, as nodal officer, fixes the size and make-up of the team after consulting the temple’s Executive Officer, the Archaeological Survey of India and the Madurai Police Commissioner. The district administration decides the time, the route and how long the team stays, and the team must leave straight after the lighting and leave nothing behind.
Only authorised Devasthanam representatives and government officials may go to the spot. “Members of the public would not be permitted to go to the location,” the bench said. Processions, public gatherings, demonstrations and slogans are barred, as are excavation, construction and any structural change. Worship at the customary sites and lawful access to the dargah and mosque must continue undisturbed.
Police must provide security, with central paramilitary help if needed. The Collector must report any obstruction to the court at once and file a compliance report within three days after the festival.
The bench was equally firm on what it did not decide. The permission is not an endorsement of any claimed custom, cannot be used as evidence of practice or to claim the same right in later years, and leaves open who owns the pillar, whether lighting there is an essential religious practice and the questions under Articles 25 and 26 of the Constitution. Those articles are already before a nine-judge Constitution Bench in the Sabarimala reference.
How the dispute reached the Supreme Court
The hill carries the Arulmigu Subramaniya Swamy temple and the Sikandar Badusha dargah. For generations the Karthigai Deepam has been lit at the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar temple. A devotee, Rama Ravikumar, asked the temple to light it also at the Deepathoon, about 50 metres from the dargah. The temple’s Executive Officer refused, and he went to the High Court.
Thiruparankundram lamp case
- December 1, 2025Justice G R Swaminathan directs the temple to light the lamp at the Deepathoon as well as the customary site
- December 3, 2025Temple does not comply; judge lets Ravikumar and others light it under CISF cover; police block access under a prohibitory order
- January 6, 2026Division Bench upholds the direction and holds the pillar stands on temple land
- June 11, 2026Tamil Nadu files its appeal in the Supreme Court
- August 3, 2026Supreme Court issues notice, declines to stay the High Court order
- November 20, 2026Stay and one-time permission for November 24
On December 1, 2025, Justice G R Swaminathan held the pillar to be a Deepathoon. When the temple did not comply, he allowed the petitioners to light it themselves on December 3. Police stopped them citing a prohibitory order, and the lamp was lit only at the customary site, amid protests and about 50 detentions. A Division Bench upheld that order the next day, and on January 6, 2026 it also upheld the main direction, calling the State’s law-and-order fears an “imaginary ghost created by state authorities for their convenience”.
The State’s petition came on June 11, after the new Tamil Nadu government took office. On August 3 the same bench issued notice but declined to stay the High Court order, and asked why a petition against a January order was filed only in June.
What each side argued
For the State, Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta said there is no proof of a custom of lighting at the pillar and that the Agamas prescribe the lamp near the Uchipillaiyar temple. Gopal Sankaranarayanan, for the Madurai Collector, said: “This pillar came into existence for a completely different purpose. Nothing to do with religious beliefs.” He called it a survey pillar, and warned that treating such markers as religious structures would spread claims. Shekhar Naphade, for the HR&CE Commissioner, asked: “If some practice has been going on for 100 years, why change it?”
For the dargah, Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi said the single judge inspected the site without notice to the dargah and that a new custom needs a civil suit, not a writ petition. Amit Tiwari said a 1923 decree gives the dargah the whole hillock. Appearing for the lead petitioner, Guru Krishnakumar showed photographs he said prove there are two separate peaks and that the Deepathoon is not on the dargah’s.
Reactions
Tamil Nadu BJP president Nainar Nagenthran called the order a “hammer blow” to communal politics. Hindu Munnani state president Kadeswara C Subramaniam called it a “historic turning point” and urged devotees to visit Thiruparankundram on November 24. K Annamalai thanked the court, asked it to consider lasting relief from next year, and said he trusted the state government “will follow the court directives”.
Mohan G, for petitioner Hindu Dharma Parishad, welcomed the ruling but called it “a temporary judgment”, with documents due in January. For the dargah, advocate M Bazeerdeen said: “We do not accept this order.” He said the side will file a review petition.
The Tamil Nadu government has issued no statement on the order that we could find; its stand is on record from its counsel in court.
What happens on November 24, and next
The lamp is to be lit on Tuesday, November 24, by the team the Collector names, at a time the administration fixes. The Hindu Munnani’s call to devotees to gather is at odds with the order, which bars the public from the spot, so the district administration’s arrangements will matter. The Collector’s report is due within three days of the festival.
The appeals will be heard in the second week of January 2027, when the court takes up ownership of the pillar and the custom claim.
The documents
- Madras High Court (Madurai Bench), common judgment of January 6, 2026, W.A.(MD) No. 3188 of 2025 and batch, The Executive Officer, Arulmigu Subramaniya Swamy Temple v Rama Ravikumar (Justices G. Jayachandran and K.K. Ramakrishnan), the judgment stayed on November 20Madras High Court, January 6, 2026
